Original size 1140x1600

«Mafia»: From Student Entertainment to International Gaming Phenomenon

Longread translated automatically
This project is a student project at the School of Design or a research project at the School of Design. This project is not commercial and serves educational purposes
The project is taking part in the competition

Concept

The board game Mafia was chosen for this study because its history demonstrates how a simple game concept can transcend its original context, spread across different countries, and evolve into numerous local and commercial variations. The game is interesting as a real cultural phenomenon: its rules were transmitted between people, adapted for diverse audiences, and its material presentation gradually became part of the gameplay experience.

The main focus of this research is on the history of the creation and spread of «Mafia,» as well as the changes that occurred to the game as it became more popular. Additional attention is given to the evolution of gameplay roles, modes, and thematic attributes.

The material was selected based on the principle of reliability and the ability to trace specific stages of the game’s development. Sources used include Dmitry Davydov’s original rules, interviews with the author, publications from library and scientific organizations, materials from board game publishers, and catalogs of commercial game sets. For theoretical analysis, we utilize Roger Cailliau’s game classification from the Russian edition of «Games and People» (2007).

The research structure is built chronologically and thematically: first, the creation and dissemination of the game are examined, followed by its subsequent evolution and material presentation, after which the game mechanics are analyzed using Cailliau’s categories. This categorization method allows us to trace how «Mafia» became a «global phenomenon, ” what modifications and changes it underwent, and why people still choose to play it 40 years after its creation.

Categorization Plan:

  1. History of the Game’s Creation and Dissemination 1.1. The Birth of „Mafia“ 1.2. Dissemination and the Emergence of International Variants
  2. Evolution of Game Rules and Material Design 2.1. Development of Roles and Game Modes 2.2. Additional Attributes and Their Influence on the Gameplay Experience
  3. „Mafia“ within Roger Cailliau’s Game Classification 3.1. Brief Terminology 3.2. Characterizing „Mafia“ through agon, alea, mimicry, and ilinx
  4. Conclusion

Key research question: How did «Mafia,» which originally was a simple game with a minimal set of components, evolve into an international cultural phenomenon with diverse rules, roles, and material formats?

Hypothesis: The widespread adoption of «Mafia» is linked to the simplicity of its core rules, the ability to pass them down orally, and the capacity to adapt them to diverse cultural contexts. The lack of a requirement for specialized game equipment and the inability to secure exclusive rights to the game idea facilitated the emergence of numerous variations. Over time, the game has evolved not only through rule modifications but also through commercial sets and immersive spaces that expand the player experience.

1. History of the Game’s Creation and Spread

1.1. The Birth of «Mafia»

Dmitry Davydov, a student at the Psychology Faculty of Moscow State University, is credited with creating the game Mafia. According to the original rules, the game first appeared in Moscow in 1986. Its core concept revolved around the confrontation between an informed minority and an uninformed majority: a small group of players knows each other and acts in concert, while the rest must identify its members based on discussions and observation of player behavior [1, 2–5].

There are discrepancies in the dating across various sources. In a 2008 interview with the newspaper Kommersant, Davydov himself stated that the game was created in 1987 [2]. Therefore, for this research, it is appropriate to cite 1986 as the date mentioned in the original rules, while separately noting the author’s testimony regarding 1987. There is no definitive basis for explaining this divergence.

The initial version was extremely simple from a material standpoint. The group only needed a standard deck of cards, paper, and pencils; the rules stipulated that even a small group could play. The cards were used to assign roles among the participants: black cards designated the Mafia, and red cards designated the civilians [1, 2–5]. Thus, the game required no special board, tokens, or complex equipment.

A notable feature of the original version was that its rules differed from the system commonly used today. For instance, the Mafia would get to know each other at the beginning of the game, and the daytime discussion and voting were organized differently than in many modern variations. Not all of the supplementary roles that became widespread later were present in the original concept [1, 2–5].

1.2. Dissemination and Emergence of International Variations

One of the main reasons for the popularization of «Mafia» was the ability to pass the game from person to person without needing to purchase a special set. The rules could be orally relayed, written down on a piece of paper, or adapted for a specific group. The American Library Association classifies «Mafia» as a so-called folk game: it has a recognizable foundation, but the specific rules and details can change depending on who and where it is played [3].

The game spread within student communities, university groups, and among people who encountered it at gatherings and while traveling. In an interview with Kommersant, Davydov recalled meeting players in the United States in 1991 who recognized «Mafia» not from him [2]. This indicates that by the early 1990s, the game had moved beyond the author’s original circle of acquaintances.

As the game spread, its thematic wrapper also evolved. In 1997, Andrew Plotkin proposed a werewolf-themed version—Werewolf. In this iteration, the Mafia transformed into werewolves, and the innocent villagers became village residents. The core principle of opposition between hidden teams remained the same [3]. This new theme allowed the game to exist independently of a criminal plot and proved more appealing to an audience drawn to folklore and fantasy aesthetics.

Different names took hold in various regions. In Eastern Europe, including Russia, the name «Mafia» is the most common. In Western countries, the name Werewolf («Werewolf»), linked to Plotkin’s thematic adaptation, is more frequently used. In the Asian region, the name Assassin («Assassin») appears. However, these boundaries are not strict—several names might be used simultaneously in certain countries or communities [3]. It is important to note that this refers primarily to regional trends, not a unified official assignment of names to specific states.

The specific nature of intellectual property protection also influenced the spread of the game. Legislation does not grant exclusive copyright to abstract ideas, concepts, principles, or gameplay mechanics. For instance, Article 1259 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation states that ideas, concepts, and methods are not considered objects of copyright; a similar approach is reflected in the materials of the U.S. Copyright Office, which separately notes that the game idea or the method of play itself is not protected, unlike the specific text of the rules or the graphic design [6; 7].

This means that the core principle of «Mafia» could be freely retold, reinterpreted, and embodied in new thematic variations. However, the specific texts of the rules, illustrations, and the design of commercial sets may hold legal protection. Thus, the lack of an exclusive right over the game mechanism itself was one factor that facilitated its adaptation and spread, though the simplicity of the rules and oral transmission of the game also played a vital role.

2. Evolution of Game Rules and Material Aesthetics

2.1. Development of Roles and Gameplay Modes

As the «Mafia» game spread, its basic system of roles became more complex. In the original version, there were two main sides—the Mafia and the civilians. Later, additional characters emerged capable of influencing the course of the game: the investigator or sheriff, the doctor, the maniac, the lover, and others. Their functions vary depending on the game version; some gain the ability to check the roles of other participants, while others can prevent elimination or act independently.

The introduction of additional characters altered the game’s balance. While participants initially relied primarily on discussion, observation, and logical deduction, the new roles added hidden gameplay mechanics and novel sources of information. Academic studies of Mafia and Werewolf also examine team interaction, the distribution of hidden information, and characters' special abilities as crucial elements of game dynamics [5].

The formats for conducting games also evolved. Beyond the classic alternating night-and-day version, shortened variants, thematic scenarios, games with a larger number of participants, and versions with additional victory conditions emerged. In some formats, the host takes on a more active role, and participants may utilize special event cards or supplementary rules.

Thus, the core mechanic of the game remains, but it has become more flexible. The variety of roles and modes has allowed for «Mafia» to be adapted to different companies, party lengths, and desired levels of difficulty.

2.2. Additional Attributes and Their Influence on the Gaming Experience

Initially, «Mafia» could be played with standard playing cards and minimal auxiliary items. However, with the release of commercial editions, the physical components became more prominent. These items began not only to help assign roles but also to build the atmosphere, support gameplay actions, and deepen participant immersion.

These examples illustrate that supplemental items serve multiple functions. Masks help organize the night phase and conceal player actions, cards make roles more tangible, and notebooks and thematic materials support the narrative atmosphere. Commercial packaging transforms a minimalistic game into a more complete product that can be purchased, gifted, and used without needing to prepare props independently.

It is also important to note that such attributes are not mandatory for the game itself. They supplement the basic rules, enhance the thematic presentation, and alter the perception of the session, but they do not negate the original principle of social interaction among participants.

3. «Mafia» in Roger Caillois’s Game Classification

3.1. Brief Terminology

To analyze the gameplay process, one can refer to Roger Caillois' classification presented in the book «Games and People» (2007). The researcher identifies four main categories: agon—competition, alea—chance, mimicry—imitation and role-playing, and ilinx—dizziness and loss of stability [4].

3.2. Characterizing the «Mafia» through agon, alea, mimicry, and ilinx

Agon — competition. This category is most clearly demonstrated in «Mafia.» Participants in two teams strive for opposing goals: the civilians attempt to figure out the mafia, while the mafia seeks to conceal their affiliation and eliminate the other players. The competition is built not on physical strength, but on the ability to persuade, analyze the behavior of others, and develop a strategy. Furthermore, participants operate within a set of universal rules that define the conditions for victory.

Alea — chance. The element of randomness is primarily present in role assignment. A player cannot always influence which role they receive and must accept the conditions set before the start of the game. However, after roles are assigned, a significant part of the gameplay depends on the decisions and actions of the participants. Therefore, randomness here sets the initial conditions rather than entirely determining the outcome.

Mimicry — imitation and embodiment. This category is related to the player adopting a specific role and creating an persona. The participant assigned the mafia role must portray an innocent civilian, conceal information, and control their behavior. The innocent civilians, in turn, can consciously display confidence or suspicion to influence the opinions of others. Players temporarily take on in-game identities that differ from their actual standing in the company.

«Mafia»: From Student Entertainment to International Gaming Phenomenon
Project created at 17.11.2026
More projects in visual research
Zahar Sarantsev
Camera Obscura — инди-поп-группа из Глазго, основанная в 1996 году. Её песни написаны в аранжировках, восходящих к поп-музыке 1960-х, а клипы и обложки на протяжении более двадцати лет отсылают к визуальной культуре прошлых десятилетий: выцветшей плёнке, музыкальным телешоу 1960-х, туристическому быту 1970-х, акварельному портрету. Ни одну из этих эпох участники группы не застали взрослыми. Исследование рассматривает, как устроено это обращение к прошлому и как оно меняется с 2001 по 2024 год.
We use cookies to improve the operation of the website and to enhance its usability. More detailed information on the use of cookies can be fo...
Show more